Battle of the ages rages in IT shops

Older workers like to do their research while yong’uns prefer efficiency

By: Sandra Gittlen

ComputerWorld Canada (19 Feb 2007)

Charleston Southern University CIO Rusty Bruns has a secret weapon to handle needy users — Buddy Gray, a 63-year-old network manager.

“His customer service is impeccable. He has the patience and knowledge to sit with a user until all their questions are answered,” Bruns said of Gray.

Bruns’ reliance on Gray, one of three workers older than 60 on Charleston Southern’s 17-person IT team, is a rarity. Many CIOs are reportedly turning away from older workers in favor of twenty-somethings, causing a battle of the ages in IT.

“Blogs everywhere are filling, debating whether the older workers are past their prime and only the young employees have value moving forward,” said Phil Murphy, principal analyst at Forrester Research.

A 2006 Intelliquest Fall Business Study bears this out as employees 50 years of age and older accounted for less than 20 per cent of the corporate IT professional workforce. Murphy said older workers are seen as having out-of-date mainframe skills while younger workers have new technology smarts.

He said the answer to stopping this generational conflict lies with CIOs. “This misconception is unnecessary. CIOs should not let things get to the point of war. If they do it’s a failure of management,” he said.

Bruns, who is in his late 40s, said he sees a lot of age discrimination in the industry but is careful to avoid it in his own organization.

“We don’t experience age discrimination here, because I hire based on personality first and technical fit second. This is so I know that individuals are able to coexist,” he said. “While there are plenty of different ages — 20s, 30s, 40s — the personalities are all similar.”

Bruns said it’s his job to see the positives of an older worker and match those to the needs of the organization. At Charleston Southern, Gray’s ability to help users resolve problems is a perfect fit for faculty members who often need more attention than other users.

The CIO understands this attention to detail might not make Gray the fastest worker on the team, but his role is critical. “The older gentlemen on the team might do 50 work orders in a week vs. the 80 to 100 that the younger worker does, but the payback we receive is worth that extra 30. I get a lot of compliments on the work that Buddy does,” he said.

The good will that Gray attracts for the team through his customer service helps when it’s time to rally support for a new project or during a difficult rollout.

Gray, a retired Navy missile inspector and six-year veteran of the IT team, enjoys working in a mix of age groups and is fond of the twenty-somethings on his team. “It’s nice to be around them and to share their joy for life. They are fun, and they tend to offer a different perspective,” he said.

Gray praises their ability to learn new technologies and multitask. “They do pick up things quicker, without a doubt,” he said. But he adds there can be a downside to this rapid pace. “They always have to have an answer immediately and sometimes that answer isn’t correct.”

Gray said he had a mentor who said something has to be tested seven times before it can be considered fixed. “The younger generation tests a solution once and considers it done,” he said.

Tony Bonne, a 27-year-old member of the university’s IT team, said the younger generation can be hasty.

“Younger people do want a problem solved quickly so they can move on and the older people spend time and do a lot of research,” he said. Bonne, a five-year-veteran of Bruns’ group, said a mixture of the generations is needed to make an organization complete. “You come out of school with all this enthusiasm and no idea what’s expected of you. It’s nice to have people around that are experienced in life and can help you channel that energy,” he said.